The thought echoed in my mind as I shifted gears: “I can’t wait until these hit the used market.” But reality quickly set in – the manual 2025 Z4 M40i isn’t likely to depreciate into my budget anytime soon. In fact, this car is poised to become a future classic, its value potentially appreciating thanks to its unique blend of modern performance and old-school driving engagement.
When this generation of Z4 first debuted, reactions were mixed. Reviews highlighted its impressive driving dynamics, but some criticized its styling and price point. Many enthusiasts clamored for a manual transmission, recognizing the chassis and powertrain’s potential for driver engagement. However, with Z4 sales figures being less than stellar and rumors of discontinuation circulating early on, a manual option seemed improbable. Until now.
When BMW announced the manual transmission for the Z4 M40i, a personal favorite among contemporary BMWs, I was ecstatic. I anticipated it would be among the best driving BMWs in years. However, after experiencing it firsthand, my expectations were surpassed. The 2025 BMW Z4 M40i with a manual isn’t just one of the best BMWs available today; it might just be the best.
Delving into the 2025 Z4 M40i Basics
The Z4 represents one half of BMW’s collaboration with Toyota. While often referred to as a convertible Supra, this comparison isn’t entirely accurate, though it serves as a useful starting point. The Z4 M40i shares its fundamental chassis and powertrain with the GR Supra 3.0, but BMW has implemented distinct steering and suspension tuning. With both models undergoing mid-cycle updates, these differences in driving feel are now even more pronounced.
Despite BMW’s “Life Cycle Impulse” (LCI), the 2025 Z4 maintains its original design language. It retains its distinctive headlights, elongated hood, wide kidney grilles, and short rear deck. While subjective, and some may not find it the most conventionally beautiful sports car, amidst BMW’s current design direction, the Z4 stands out as arguably one of their most aesthetically pleasing models. It possesses a unique character that is genuinely appealing. The test vehicle’s Frozen Deep Green paint is striking, although personally, Thundernight Metallic purple remains my preferred choice.
Stepping inside the 2025 Z4 is a welcome reminder of BMW’s interior design prowess from years past. The cabin prioritizes functionality and driver focus over unnecessary frills. All essential controls are intuitively placed and easily accessible. The seats offer excellent comfort for extended drives and ample support during spirited cornering. The build quality is substantial, promising long-term durability. The two-tone Cognac and black interior of the test car complemented the matte green exterior exceptionally well.
The Thrill of Driving the Manual 2025 BMW Z4 M40i
This is where the 2025 Z4 M40i truly shines. BMW’s B58 engine, the 3.0-liter turbocharged inline-six, is globally recognized as one of the finest six-cylinder engines available. It delivers effortless power, refined smoothness, and a compelling soundtrack, particularly enjoyable in the Z4’s open-top configuration. While the B58 has been around for nearly a decade, its excellence remains undisputed. What truly elevates the driving experience is the new manual transmission. Historically, BMW manuals have been criticized for their vague, rubbery feel and less-than-ideal clutch engagement. While the clutch in the Z4 still retains some of that familiar BMW feel, the shifter itself is a marked improvement. Perhaps it’s a matter of personal evolution, but the manual gearbox in the 2025 Z4 is the most engaging and satisfying manual BMW I’ve experienced in recent years. The synergy between the engine and transmission is simply exhilarating.
The pure joy of driving a lightweight, two-seat convertible powered by a six-cylinder engine, controlled by three pedals and a manual stick, is a rare and special experience. The 2025 Z4 M40i manual embodies this experience perfectly. While the steering might still lack some ultimate feedback, it’s well-weighted, and the front end response is remarkably precise. The car’s responsiveness and directional changes are felt directly, creating an incredibly connected driving sensation. While there might be other excellent convertible sports cars available, the Z4 M40i possesses a unique, old-school hot-rod character, capable of easily breaking rear-wheel traction on command, setting it apart from the competition.
The suspension of the 2025 Z4 M40i also deserves high praise. The ability to customize driving modes, with Comfort suspension settings combined with Sport settings for other parameters, proved ideal for diverse driving conditions. Despite its low stance and large wheels – 19-inch front and 20-inch rear – the Z4 delivers a surprisingly comfortable ride, even on less-than-perfect road surfaces.
Even with the top up in inclement weather, the 2025 Z4 remains composed. During a particularly heavy downpour, the soft top’s sound insulation proved surprisingly effective, creating a comfortable and quiet cabin environment for longer drives.
High Points and Minor Drawbacks of the 2025 Z4 M40i
The addictive power of the 2025 Z4 M40i is a significant highlight. BMW claims a 0-60 mph time of 4.2 seconds with the manual transmission (3.9 seconds for the automatic), but the raw acceleration feel is more impactful than numbers suggest. The car pushes you back into your seat with satisfying force and a glorious engine note, all while offering the engaging control of manual gear changes. Beyond performance, the Z4 excels as a convertible. The power-operated soft top retracts in just 10 seconds and can be operated at speeds up to 30 mph. Wind noise with the top down and windows up is minimal, even at highway speeds. Surprisingly, the trunk space is also quite generous for a compact convertible.
However, there are minor criticisms. The digital instrument cluster remains a point of contention. It’s arguably both visually uninspired and functionally confusing. The clutch, while improved, still retains a somewhat vague engagement point and excessive springback. Nevertheless, after acclimating to the manual clutch in both the Toyota Supra and the Z4, it becomes manageable. Price is another consideration. At an as-tested price of $77,470, the 2025 Z4 M40i is pricier than more powerful and faster cars like the BMW M2, Chevrolet Corvette, and Ford Mustang Dark Horse.
2025 BMW Z4 M40i: Features, Options, and the Competitive Landscape
The 2025 Z4 M40i comes well-equipped as standard. Being the top-tier Z4 model, it includes features like adaptive suspension, heated seats, a heated steering wheel, and an M Sport rear differential. The base price for the four-cylinder Z4 sDrive30i starts at $54,595.
As expected with BMW, numerous optional extras are available, adding to the overall cost. The Frozen Deep Green metallic paint is a $2,950 option. The Premium Package adds $1,250. Even the wireless charging pad is a $200 standalone option. Crucially, the manual transmission is bundled within the $3,500 Handschalter Package.
The market for premium, rear-wheel-drive, two-seat roadsters is limited. The primary competitors to the 2025 Z4 are the Porsche 718 Boxster and Chevrolet Corvette Convertible. However, the Boxster starts at a higher price ($76,895) and comes standard with a four-cylinder engine. The Corvette Convertible ($76,995) also has a higher starting price and doesn’t offer a manual transmission. For those seeking a traditional front-engine roadster experience, the Z4 stands out as one of the few remaining options. While the Mazda MX-5 is available at a significantly lower price point, it represents a compromise in both performance and luxury compared to the Z4.
Fuel Efficiency of the 2025 Z4 M40i
Cars like the Z4 are often purchased as secondary or recreational vehicles. However, fuel economy remains a consideration for most buyers. The 2025 BMW Z4 M40i performs surprisingly well in this area. EPA estimates are 19 mpg city, 26 mpg highway, and 22 mpg combined with the manual transmission, outperforming both the Boxster and Corvette in fuel efficiency. Real-world figures may vary, but the Z4 is relatively efficient for its performance class.
EPA Source
Verdict: The 2025 BMW Z4 M40i – A Future Classic in the Making
Objectively, the 2025 Z4 M40i might not be the most rational purchase in its price bracket. A Porsche Boxster, arguably a more focused sports car, is available for a similar price. However, the Z4 appeals to a different emotional core. It’s a car you buy because you connect with it on a personal level. And for those who do, its objective value proposition becomes secondary to the emotional reward it delivers. Looking ahead 5-10 years, the 2025 Z4 M40i manual presents a compelling case for future classic status. As the automotive landscape increasingly shifts towards electric and hybrid vehicles, manual, rear-drive sports cars will become highly sought after by enthusiasts. The Z4, with its convertible top and engaging driving dynamics, is perfectly positioned to become a future icon.
Even in the present, the 2025 BMW Z4 with a manual transmission is an exceptional sports car. It offers a driving experience that is uniquely engaging in the current market. It’s not just the best-driving BMW currently available; it’s arguably the best driving BMW since the legendary M5 CS.
| 2025 BMW Z4 M40i “Handschalter Package” Specs |
|---|
| Base Price (as tested) |
| Powertrain |
| Horsepower |
| Torque |
| Seating Capacity |
| Cargo Volume |
| Curb Weight |
| 0-60 mph |
| Top Speed |
| EPA Fuel Economy |
| Quick Take |
| Score |
