Choosing the right tonneau cover for your pickup truck is a decision that balances security, convenience, and style. Among the various types available, retractable tonneau covers stand out for their unique blend of robust protection and full truck bed accessibility. If you’re in the market for a tonneau cover that offers both security and versatility without compromising on truck bed usage, then a retractable model might be the perfect solution.
Retractable tonneau covers are designed to roll smoothly into a canister, usually located at the front of the truck bed near the cab. This mechanism allows for complete and instant access to the entire truck bed when needed, without obstructing the rear window view. This is a significant advantage over folding or one-piece covers, especially for those who frequently haul large items or tow trailers. However, with a variety of brands and models on the market, selecting the best retractable tonneau cover can be overwhelming.
To simplify your search, we’ve rigorously tested and evaluated numerous retractable tonneau covers, consulting with industry experts and putting each cover through its paces on a range of pickup trucks. Our aim is to provide you with a clear, data-backed guide to the top options available, ensuring you make an informed decision that fits your specific needs and budget. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll delve into the benefits and drawbacks of retractable tonneau covers, explore key buying considerations, and present our top recommendations for the Best Retractable Tonneau Covers of the year.
Retractable Tonneau Covers: Our Hands-On Testing Methodology
At Automoblog, we believe in thorough, hands-on testing to deliver trustworthy and practical product recommendations. When it comes to tonneau covers, we go beyond surface-level assessments, scrutinizing each product across several critical criteria. Our testing process is designed to mimic real-world usage, evaluating factors that directly impact a truck owner’s experience. Here’s a closer look at our rigorous testing methodology:
We evaluate each tonneau cover based on the following key aspects:
-
Ease of Installation: We assess how straightforward it is for an average truck owner to install the tonneau cover at home. Covers that require minimal tools, have clear instructions, and can be installed quickly score higher in this category. We note down the time taken for installation and any specific challenges encountered. Poorly written manuals and complicated steps lead to lower scores.
-
Ease of Use: This criterion focuses on the daily operation of the tonneau cover. We examine how smoothly it opens and closes, the functionality of latches, and the effort required for retraction and extension. Retractable covers should glide effortlessly along their rails without jamming or sticking. Lightweight designs and user-friendly mechanisms contribute to a higher ease-of-use rating.
-
Durability: Durability is paramount for a tonneau cover designed to withstand the elements and secure your truck bed. We evaluate the materials used, the overall construction, and long-term reliability. Besides our direct experience, we delve into customer reviews to gauge how well each cover holds up over years of use. Factors like resistance to weather, impacts, and wear-and-tear are carefully considered.
-
Functionality: Beyond the basic operation, we assess the practical functionality of each tonneau cover. This includes aspects like water resistance, security features, and any additional functionalities such as integrated lighting or automatic operation. We test water resistance by simulating rain conditions and observe any water intrusion into the truck bed. Security is evaluated based on locking mechanisms and the overall robustness of the cover against potential theft.
To ensure our tests are relevant and applicable to a wide range of truck owners, we utilize a diverse fleet of test vehicles, including:
- 2013 Toyota Tacoma (Standard Cab) with a 6.0-ft., 2.0-in. bed
- 2016 Toyota Tundra with a 5.0-ft., 7.0-in. bed
- 2022 Nissan Frontier Crew Cab with a 5.0-ft. bed
- 2016 Chevy Colorado with a 5.0-ft. bed
- 2017 Toyota Tundra with a 5.0-ft., 7.0-in. bed
- 2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Trail Boss with a 5.0-ft., 8.0-in. bed
- 2024 Chevrolet Silverado 2500 with a 6.0-ft., 9.0-in. bed
By testing on various truck models, we gain a comprehensive understanding of how each tonneau cover performs across different truck bed sizes and configurations. After installation, we rigorously test all features and leave the covers on our test trucks for extended periods to monitor their performance over time, experiencing them in various weather conditions and usage scenarios.
Scoring System:
Each tonneau cover is awarded a star rating from 1.0 to 5.0 in each of the categories mentioned above. Here’s a breakdown of our star rating system:
- 5.0 Stars: Exceptional performance, ranking among the very best in the category. Installation is incredibly easy, possibly tool-free and completed in minutes. Durability is top-notch, built with the strongest materials.
- 4.0 Stars: Above-average performance. Installation might require basic tools but remains quick and manageable. Ease of use is excellent, possibly featuring slam latches or convenient retraction mechanisms.
- 3.0 Stars: Average or typical performance. Installation time is moderate (around 20-30 minutes), and functionality is standard, lacking standout features.
- 2.0 Stars: Below-average performance, indicating adequacy but with noticeable shortcomings. Fit might be imperfect, or the cover may not feel completely secure.
- 1.0 Star: Significantly below expectations. Installation may be extremely difficult, fitment poor, or durability severely compromised, potentially failing during testing.
Our detailed scoring system ensures that our recommendations are based on objective assessments across all critical aspects of tonneau cover performance. This rigorous testing process allows us to confidently recommend the best retractable tonneau covers to our readers.
Expert Insights on Retractable Tonneau Covers
To provide a well-rounded perspective, we consulted Chris King, Director of Marketing at RealTruck, a seasoned expert with over 25 years of experience in the automotive aftermarket industry. King shared valuable insights into the key considerations when choosing a retractable tonneau cover and differentiated them from other types of covers.
According to King, the primary factors truck owners should weigh when selecting a tonneau cover are cost, security, and use case. These three variables form a crucial framework for making the right choice.
“There’s not a single magic question to ask somebody if they’re interested in a tonneau cover, but we recommend truck owners consider three variables: price, level of security, and use case.”
Cost Considerations for Retractable Tonneau Covers
Retractable tonneau covers typically occupy a higher price bracket compared to soft or even hard folding covers. Entry-level retractable covers start around $1,000, while high-end models with advanced features can reach upwards of $4,000. The average price point for a quality retractable tonneau cover generally hovers around $1,900.
| Price Range | Cost |
|---|---|
| Low End | $1,000 |
| Typical Price | $1,900 |
| High End | $4,000 |
While the initial investment is higher, the price reflects the advanced engineering, durable materials, and enhanced features that retractable covers offer. The cost difference between models is often attributed to the materials used and additional functionalities.
Material Matters:
The two primary materials used in constructing retractable tonneau covers are aluminum and polycarbonate composites.
“Many polycarbonate tops are constructed from a single piece, engineered to retract without joints or hinges that can trap dust, wear out, or freeze. They are also UV- and impact-resistant. The aluminum slats are also going to be less susceptible to impact damage.”
Aluminum covers generally offer superior durability and strength but come at a higher cost. Polycarbonate options, like the GatorTrax, provide a balance of durability and affordability, making them a popular choice for budget-conscious buyers.
Added Features Impact Price:
Beyond materials, additional features significantly influence the price of retractable tonneau covers. These features often enhance convenience and functionality:
- Automatic Retraction: Some premium models integrate with your truck’s key fob or offer smartphone app control for automated opening and closing. This adds a layer of convenience, particularly for those who frequently access their truck bed.
- Integrated Lighting: Built-in LED bed lights are a valuable feature for improved visibility inside the truck bed, especially during nighttime loading and unloading.
- Enhanced Weatherproofing: While most retractable covers aim for water resistance, some models offer superior sealing and drainage systems to minimize water intrusion, especially in heavy rain.
Security Advantages of Retractable Tonneau Covers
Security is a major selling point for retractable tonneau covers. Constructed from robust materials like aluminum or heavy-duty polycarbonate, these covers offer excellent protection against theft and weather. Unlike soft covers that can be easily cut open, retractable covers provide a hard, impenetrable barrier for your truck bed.
For those prioritizing security but seeking a more budget-friendly option, hard folding tonneau covers present a viable alternative. We’ve previously tested and recommended the BAKFlip G2 and Gator EFX as excellent hard folding options, offering a good balance of security and cost.
Use Cases and Bed Access
Retractable tonneau covers excel in providing full and unobstructed access to the truck bed. Their retracting design, which rolls the cover into a compact canister, ensures the rear window remains completely clear. This is a critical advantage for truck owners who frequently tow trailers, especially fifth-wheel or gooseneck trailers.
“Retractable covers would roll up and be out of the way for a fifth wheel or gooseneck trailer. A hard folding cover would fold up against the cab and be out of the way. However, if you’re towing a trailer and it’s going to be hooked up for a while, I certainly wouldn’t recommend blocking your rear window for that long of a period.”
While some soft and hard folding covers also offer full bed access, retractable covers offer this benefit without requiring complete removal of the cover. Soft covers, while affordable and easily removable, offer less security. Hard folding covers provide a middle ground but may sometimes obstruct the rear window when fully opened, depending on the design.
Key Benefits of Retractable Tonneau Covers
Choosing a retractable tonneau cover brings a host of advantages to truck owners:
-
Superior Durability: Constructed from robust materials like aluminum or polycarbonate, these covers are built to last, resisting impacts, weather, and wear.
-
Full Bed Access: Retract into a canister, providing complete and instant access to the entire truck bed without obstructing the rear window.
-
Enhanced Security: Offer excellent theft deterrence, protecting cargo from prying eyes and opportunistic thieves.
-
Convenient Features: Many models offer optional features like automatic retraction, key fob integration, and integrated bed lighting, adding to user convenience.
Downsides of Retractable Tonneau Covers
Despite their numerous benefits, retractable tonneau covers also have a few potential drawbacks:
-
More Complex Installation: Installation can be more involved compared to soft or folding covers, sometimes requiring electrical connections for automatic models.
-
Less Easily Removable: Retractable covers are not designed for frequent removal. Once installed, they are intended to remain in place.
-
Higher Initial Cost: Generally more expensive than soft or hard folding tonneau covers due to their complex mechanisms and durable materials.
It’s important to weigh these potential downsides against the benefits in the context of your specific needs and usage patterns.
Retractable Tonneau Cover Buying Guide
When navigating the market for the best retractable tonneau cover, several factors should guide your decision. Based on our extensive testing, the GatorTrax, Retrax EQ, and Gator Recoil emerge as top contenders, each catering to different priorities and budgets. Beyond these, other highly-regarded options include the Truck Covers USA American Roll Cover, RetraxPRO MX, and Pace Edwards Jackrabbit, based on customer reviews and industry reputation.
To aid your selection, consider these key factors:
-
Material: Aluminum offers maximum durability and security, while polycarbonate provides a more budget-friendly yet still robust alternative.
-
Retraction Style: Choose between manual and automatic retraction based on your convenience preferences and budget. Automatic systems offer push-button ease but come at a premium.
-
Warranty: A longer warranty period indicates manufacturer confidence in product quality and durability.
-
Features: Evaluate desired features like automatic operation, integrated lighting, and water resistance based on your specific needs and usage scenarios.
-
Budget: Retractable tonneau covers span a wide price range. Determine your budget upfront and prioritize features that align with your financial considerations.
Here’s a comparison table of our top recommended retractable tonneau covers:
| Brand/Model | Starting Price (Approx.) | Material | Warranty | Key Features |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GatorTrax Tonneau Cover | $1,600 | Polycarbonate | One Year | Durable polycarbonate, locks in any position |
| Retrax EQ | $3,200 | Aluminum | Five Years | Automatic, key fob operation, integrated bed lights |
| Gator Recoil | $900 | Aluminum | Two Years | Affordable aluminum, smooth operation |
| Truck Covers USA American Roll Cover | $2,500 | Aluminum | Two Years | Heavy-duty, 500lb weight capacity |
| RetraxPRO MX Tonneau Cover | $1,950 | Aluminum | Limited Lifetime | Flush mount, 500lb weight capacity |
| Pace Edwards Jackrabbit Tonneau Cover | $1,300 | Aluminum/ArmorTek® | Five Years | Spring tension retraction, low profile |
Note: Prices are approximate and can vary based on truck bed size and retailer.
To compile this guide, our team at Automoblog thoroughly researches across various sources, including DIY mechanic forums, auto enthusiast communities, manufacturer websites, and customer reviews on platforms like RealTruck and Amazon. We prioritize feedback concerning build quality, ease of installation, warranty experiences, customer service, and overall reliability to provide you with well-rounded recommendations.
Based on our testing and research, we’ve identified the GatorTrax as the best overall retractable tonneau cover, the Retrax EQ as the best high-end option, and the Gator Recoil as the best value choice.
Best Retractable Tonneau Cover Overall: GatorTrax
[
GatorTrax Fast Facts:
- Starting Price: From $1,600
- Retraction Style: Manual
- Material: Polycarbonate Composite
- Warranty: One Year
The GatorTrax stands out as our top pick for the best retractable tonneau cover due to its exceptional balance of durability, security, and user-friendly design. Unlike many covers with fixed locking points, the GatorTrax can be locked in any position along the rail, offering unparalleled versatility. Constructed from robust polycarbonate, it proves remarkably durable in real-world use, despite being generally less impact-resistant than aluminum.
GatorTrax Performance Ratings (Out of 5.0 Stars):
| Category | Score |
|---|---|
| Fit | 3.5 |
| Ease of Use | 4.5 |
| Durability | 5.0 |
| Overall Rating | 4.3 |
Pros:
- Available in matte or gloss finishes to match your truck’s style.
- Locks securely in any position along the rail for maximum flexibility.
- No-drill installation for most truck applications, simplifying setup.
Cons:
- Installation instructions could be clearer, a common issue with many tonneau covers.
Our Hands-On Experience:
Like many tonneau covers we’ve tested, the GatorTrax’s printed installation manual isn’t the most user-friendly. However, RealTruck’s excellent customer service, including a helpful live chat option, is readily available to assist with any questions. We recommend consulting installation videos on RealTruck’s YouTube channel for a more intuitive guide.
The GatorTrax feels substantial, noticeably heavier than some competitors, which we attribute to its robust panel design and a testament to its durability. Once installed, the sealed ball bearings ensure incredibly smooth manual retraction, operating seamlessly. The cover and tailgate can be operated independently, adding to its convenience.
Considering its price, security features, and overall functionality, the GatorTrax offers the most compelling value proposition, earning it our “Best Overall” designation.
What Customers Are Saying:
RealTruck Customer Review Score: 4.5 out of 5.0 stars (based on approximately 1,000 reviews).
Customer feedback largely echoes our positive experience. Many reviewers praise the GatorTrax for its easy installation (despite the manual) and exceptional water resistance. Some users even report successfully pressure washing their trucks without water intrusion. However, a few negative reviews mention canister rattling during driving or concerns about build quality and water resistance in specific scenarios.
Best Overall: GatorTrax
- Impact-resistant cover locks securely at any point along the rail.
- Smooth manual retraction thanks to maintenance-free sealed ball bearings.
- Compact 11″x11″ canister maximizes truck bed cargo space.
Check Best Price Guarantee Automoblog may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
Best High-End Option: Retrax EQ
Retrax EQ Fast Facts:
- Price: $3,200
- Retraction Style: Automatic
- Material: Aluminum
- Warranty: Five Years
For truck owners seeking the pinnacle of convenience and features, the Retrax EQ is the best retractable tonneau cover in the high-end category. This cover boasts automatic operation, seamlessly integrating with your truck’s factory key fob. Beyond key fob control, it offers Bluetooth connectivity via the Retrax app and optional keypad access, providing multiple control options. Integrated bed lights further enhance its premium appeal.
Retrax EQ Performance Ratings (Out of 5.0 Stars):
| Category | Score |
|---|---|
| Ease of Installation | 2.5 |
| Ease of Use | 5.0 |
| Durability | 4.5 |
| Overall Rating | 4.0 |
Pros:
- Automatic operation via key fob, app, or optional keypad.
- Ultra-low profile design for a sleek, integrated look.
- Built-in LED bed lights for enhanced nighttime visibility.
Cons:
- High price point, reflecting its premium features.
- More complex installation due to electrical integration.
Our Hands-On Experience:
Installing the Retrax EQ is more time-consuming due to the electrical integration required for its automatic features. However, the added effort pays off in enhanced convenience. While the physical cover installation is similar to other retractable models, the Retrax EQ necessitates wiring the canister to your truck’s battery and installing a control module.
While not requiring professional installation, the process is more complex. We dedicated a full afternoon to ensure proper setup. Installation instructions vary by vehicle, but RealTruck provides helpful resources, including detailed videos like this Retrax EQ installation video. RealTruck’s 24/7 customer support proved invaluable when we encountered a minor snag, connecting us quickly with knowledgeable assistance.
Once installed, the Retrax EQ is a joy to use. Key fob integration is seamless, and while the automatic operation is deliberate rather than rapid, it’s consistently smooth. The integrated bed lights are a standout feature, significantly improving nighttime truck bed access.
Best High-End Option: Retrax EQ
- Dual Helical Cable Drive System with smooth “glide tracks”.
- Operates via factory key fob, Retrax app, or optional touchpad.
- Compatible with popular T-Slot accessories for customization.
Check Best Price Guarantee Automoblog may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
What Customers Are Saying:
As a newer product, Retrax EQ customer reviews are still emerging, but initial feedback is overwhelmingly positive. Customers praise Retrax’s responsive email support and the cover’s exceeding expectations in terms of quality.
Best Low-Cost Option: Gator Recoil
Gator Recoil Fast Facts:
- Price: $900
- Retraction Style: Manual
- Material: Aluminum
- Warranty: Two Years
For truck owners seeking an affordable entry point into retractable tonneau covers without sacrificing essential quality, the Gator Recoil is the best retractable tonneau cover in the low-cost category. Despite its budget-friendly price, the Gator Recoil offers impressive features like a quick-release hatch and a robust ball-bearing design for smooth, reliable operation. Constructed from matte black powder-coated aluminum, it provides durability and UV resistance. Adjustable latch stops enhance security by allowing locking at multiple points along the truck bed.
Gator Recoil Performance Ratings (Out of 5.0 Stars):
| Category | Score |
|---|---|
| Ease of Installation | 3.5 |
| Ease of Use | 4.0 |
| Durability | 4.5 |
| Overall Rating | 4.0 |
Pros:
- Enhanced security with additional locking positions.
- Self-compacting design for efficient retraction.
- Durable aluminum construction for long-lasting performance.
Cons:
- Installation can be more challenging compared to simpler cover types.
Our Hands-On Experience:
As a retractable cover, the Gator Recoil requires more installation effort than hard folding or soft covers. However, its clamp-based design provides enhanced security and stability compared to even lower-priced options.
Once installed, the Recoil operates flawlessly. We were impressed by the quality of its components, particularly the slam latches, which contribute to smooth, seamless operation. We noted some bending in the rubber stripping upon unboxing, but this flattened out once the cover was fully installed and secured.
What Customers Are Saying:
RealTruck Customer Review Score: 3.9 out of 5.0 stars (based on over 800 reviews).
The Gator Recoil is a popular entry-level retractable tonneau cover, with many customers praising its quality relative to its affordable price. Installation is a common point of feedback, with some finding it challenging, which aligns with our experience that retractable covers generally require more involved installation.
Other Highly-Rated Retractable Tonneau Covers
While we haven’t yet tested the following covers in person, they are worth considering based on their features and strong customer reviews:
-
Truck Covers USA American Roll Cover: A premium, heavy-duty retractable cover manufactured in the USA, known for its robust construction and 500lb weight capacity. Customers consistently praise its durability and Truck Covers USA’s excellent customer service. Some note potential issues with freezing in winter and less-than-perfect water resistance.
-
RetraxPRO MX Tonneau Cover: A durable aluminum retractable cover backed by a limited lifetime warranty. It features a flush-mount design and a 500lb weight capacity. Reviewers appreciate its ease of use and security, although some mention minor water intrusion in heavy rain.
-
Pace Edwards Jackrabbit Tonneau Cover: Features a spring-tension design for smooth retraction and an ArmorTek® overlay for enhanced weather resistance. Optional explorer rails allow for roof rack integration. Customers generally praise its durability and Pace Edwards’ customer service, but installation is sometimes described as challenging, and drainage tube issues are occasionally reported.
Best Retractable Tonneau Cover: The Bottom Line
- Top Retractable Tonneau Cover: GatorTrax Tonneau Cover
- Premium Pick: RealTruck Retrax EQ
- Best Value Retractable Tonneau Cover: Gator Recoil
Other noteworthy retractable tonneau covers (untested by us):
- Truck Covers USA American Roll Cover
- RetraxPRO MX Tonneau Cover
- Pace Edwards Jackrabbit Tonneau Cover
Frequently Asked Questions About Retractable Tonneau Covers
Are retractable tonneau covers worth the investment?
While retractable tonneau covers are more expensive than soft or hard folding alternatives, their convenience, ease of use, and enhanced security make them a worthwhile investment for many truck owners.
Are Retrax and GatorTrax the same company?
While both brands offer retractable tonneau covers with similar designs, Retrax and GatorTrax are distinct brands with differences in features, finishes, and warranties.
How secure are tonneau covers in general?
Most tonneau covers are designed to remain securely attached to the truck bed. However, for theft protection, hard tonneau covers, particularly retractable and hard folding models with locking mechanisms, offer significantly greater security than soft covers.
Do tonneau covers improve fuel efficiency?
Studies, including research from Grand Valley State University, indicate that tonneau covers can improve gas mileage by reducing aerodynamic drag and lift created by an open truck bed. This aerodynamic improvement, combined with security benefits, makes tonneau covers a popular truck accessory.
What is considered the top retractable truck cover overall?
We recommend the GatorTrax Tonneau Cover as one of the best retractable truck covers due to its excellent blend of utility and moderate cost. However, the ideal choice depends on individual needs and budget. The Gator Recoil offers a more affordable option, while the Truck Covers USA American Roll Cover caters to those seeking maximum durability.
What are the different types of tonneau covers available?
Tonneau covers are broadly classified as soft or hard covers. Soft covers include roll-up and folding designs. Hard covers encompass folding, retractable, and one-piece models. Each type presents unique advantages and disadvantages, with hard covers generally offering superior security and durability at a higher price point compared to soft covers.
