Choosing between the Bmw M3 Comp and the Porsche 718 GTS 4.0 often comes down to personal priorities. For those considering both, real-world experiences from owners offer invaluable insights. One owner who has both the 718 GTS 4.0 PDK and the G80 M3 Comp highlights key differences that can guide your decision.
The BMW M3 Comp emerges as the more comfortable and practical daily driver. It’s undeniably faster in a straight line and holds its own on larger tracks. However, the Porsche 718 GTS 4.0 brings a raw and engaging driving experience, particularly when equipped with a performance exhaust system. The fun factor leans heavily towards the GTS 4.0. Ultimately, the choice is between a well-rounded, comfortable sport sedan (BMW M3 Comp) and a more intensely driver-focused coupe (Porsche 718 GTS 4.0). Your preference hinges on whether you prioritize everyday usability or pure driving thrills. Resale value is another point to consider, where the Porsche 718 GTS 4.0 is likely to excel, potentially even appreciating in value due to future model shifts towards electrification.
Another driver, who previously considered the same options and ultimately chose the BMW M3 Comp, reinforces this perspective. If a backseat and substantial trunk space aren’t necessities, the 718 GT4 (similar in spirit to the GTS 4.0) is recommended as a purer driver’s car. Its value retention is a bonus if your preferences evolve. The deciding factor for choosing the M3 Comp was family planning, where the added practicality became essential. Those still enjoying a child-free lifestyle might find the Porsche’s focused nature more appealing.
Ultimately, both are exceptional vehicles. The best choice depends on your lifestyle and what you seek most in a sports car.
