Sixteen years fly by, and suddenly, that little one is ready for their first car. Whether it’s a rite of passage or a graduation gift, finding the right “starter car” is a crucial task for parents. If you’re searching for a reliable, safe, and affordable vehicle to put your young driver behind the wheel, you’ve come to the right place. We’ve done the research to compile a list of excellent used cars that fit the bill as Good Starter Cars.
What exactly defines a good starter car? For us, it boils down to these key factors:
- Safety First: Above all else, a starter car must be safe. Every vehicle on our list earned strong safety ratings when new. While modern cars boast the latest safety tech, a brand-new car isn’t typically a “starter car” in the practical sense. We focus on reliable used models with a proven safety record for their time.
- Affordability is Key: Starter cars should be budget-friendly. “Affordable” can mean different things to different families, but our recommendations include several models that are readily available in good condition with reasonable mileage for under $8,000.
- Humility and Responsibility: A starter car is about learning and responsibility, not showing off. You won’t find any flashy sports cars here. We’re focusing on vehicles that encourage safe driving habits and won’t tempt young drivers to take unnecessary risks.
- Proven Reliability: Our list focuses on vehicles from mainstream brands sold between 2000 and 2010, known for their reliability and longevity. If none of our suggestions quite fit your needs, always prioritize safety ratings and reliability research before making a purchase for your new driver. Remember, safety is paramount.
Let’s dive into some specific models that make excellent good starter cars:
Reliable and Safe Sedans for First-Time Drivers
Ford Five Hundred (2005-2006): A Volvo-Based Bargain
The Ford Five Hundred, introduced in 2005, is a full-size sedan built on a robust Volvo platform, offering a surprising level of safety and comfort for its price point. While the standard 3.0-liter V6 engine might be considered adequate rather than powerful, it prioritizes fuel efficiency and dependability. Front-wheel drive models came with a Continuously Variable Transmission (CVT), while All-Wheel Drive (AWD) versions offered a conventional automatic.
Popular with mature drivers, you can often find well-maintained, low-mileage Ford Five Hundreds for under $7,500. It might not be the flashiest car, but its safety, spaciousness, and affordability make it a practical choice for a first car. Down the line, there’s always time for a Mustang Convertible!
Ford Taurus (2008-2009): The Refined Five Hundred Successor
The 2008 and 2009 Ford Taurus models represent a significant upgrade over the Five Hundred, essentially being restyled and improved versions. Ford replaced the less powerful 3.0-liter V6 with a more robust 3.5-liter V6, and the CVT was replaced with a smoother 6-speed automatic transmission. All-wheel drive remained available for drivers in snowy climates.
Like the Five Hundred, the Taurus appealed to a similar demographic, meaning it’s relatively easy to find low-mileage examples in excellent condition. While prices are slightly higher than the Five Hundred, the Taurus offers enhanced performance and refinement, making it an even more appealing option in the good starter cars category.
Mercury Montego (2005-2006) & Mercury Sable (2008-2009): Hidden Gems in the Ford Family
Consider the Mercury Montego (2005-2006) and Mercury Sable (2008-2009) as closely related cousins to the Ford Five Hundred and Taurus, respectively. Mercury, Ford’s now-discontinued mid-luxury brand, offered these models with slightly more upscale styling cues. The Montego shares the Five Hundred’s Volvo platform and 3.0-liter V6, while the Sable mirrors the updated Taurus with the 3.5-liter V6 and 6-speed automatic.
Because Mercury was a less popular brand, you might find even better deals on Montego and Sable models compared to their Ford counterparts. They offer the same core strengths – safety, spaciousness, and reliability – making them smart choices for good starter cars, especially if you’re looking for a bargain. Don’t hesitate to negotiate!
Practical and Safe SUVs & Crossovers for New Drivers
Honda CR-V (2002-2004 & 2007-2009): The Undisputed Crossover King
The Honda CR-V, particularly the second (2002-2004) and third (2007-2009) generations, is a perennial favorite and for good reason. These compact crossover SUVs are renowned for their reliability, fuel efficiency, and practicality. They also offer a higher seating position for better visibility and available all-wheel drive for added confidence in various weather conditions. While the 2002-2004 models have a 3-star rollover rating which is something to be aware of, overall the CR-V is considered very safe for its age.
CR-Vs are incredibly popular and known for their longevity. A hand-me-down CR-V from a family member that’s been well-maintained is an ideal starter car. Finding low-mileage examples under $10,000 might be challenging, but their reputation for reliability and resale value makes them a worthwhile investment as good starter cars.
Honda Element (2008-2010): The Utilitarian Box of Safety
The Honda Element, especially the 2008-2010 models, is a unique and surprisingly practical choice. Sharing a platform with the second-generation CR-V, the Element stands out with its boxy, utilitarian design and incredibly durable interior. Crucially, the 2008-2010 Elements earned top safety ratings, including a 5-star overall crash-test rating and IIHS “Top Safety Pick.”
With seating for four, the Element limits the number of passengers your young driver can carry, which can be a subtle safety benefit. Its boxy shape translates to excellent cargo space and versatility. While its styling is definitely an “acquired taste,” this uniqueness often keeps prices reasonable, making it a value-packed and safe option among good starter cars. The pictured SC trim with body-colored panels offers a slightly more refined look, while other trims feature more rugged gray cladding.
Hyundai Santa Fe (2007-2009): Safe and Stylish Value
The Hyundai Santa Fe, specifically the 2007-2009 generation, represents a turning point for Hyundai in terms of design and quality. This midsize crossover SUV moved away from earlier, less refined styling to adopt a more conservative and appealing aesthetic. Available with two different V6 engines and optional all-wheel drive, the Santa Fe offers a good balance of power and capability. Some models even came with a third-row seat, offering occasional extra passenger capacity.
The Santa Fe is known for its durability and safety, often coming in at a lower price point than Honda CR-V models of similar age. We recommend the SE and Limited trims for their features, but the base GLS trim is a cost-effective option focused on value and lower maintenance. For families prioritizing space, safety, and affordability, the Santa Fe is a strong contender in the good starter cars category.
Subaru Forester (2001-2002 & 2003-2008): The Ugly Duckling with a Heart of Gold
The Subaru Forester, particularly the first (2001-2002) and second (2003-2008) generations, is a bit of an “ugly duckling” in terms of styling, but it’s packed with substance. Subaru built the Forester by combining a wagon-like body with the Impreza platform, raising the suspension for better ground clearance, creating one of the original crossover SUVs. The 2001 Forester earned excellent crash-test ratings, and Subaru’s commitment to safety has continued since.
Reliable, practical, and capable in all weather conditions thanks to standard all-wheel drive, the Forester is a fantastic choice for a starter car. Its somewhat unassuming styling might not impress friends, but its safety, dependability, and utility are exactly what you should prioritize in a first vehicle. Steer clear of the turbocharged 2.5XT model if you’re looking for responsible driving habits and stick with the naturally aspirated 2.5X for a perfect good starter car.
Conclusion: Prioritize Safety and Smart Choices
Choosing a good starter car is about balancing safety, affordability, and practicality. While newer cars offer advanced safety features, these older models on our list provide a strong foundation of safety and reliability at a much more accessible price point. Remember to research specific model year safety ratings and prioritize vehicles that have been well-maintained. A starter car is a stepping stone to driving independence and responsibility – choose wisely and prioritize your young driver’s safety above all else.
