Key Fob Stolen high urgency

Key Fob Stolen: What to Do Now (2024 Tesla Model Y, US)

If your 2024 Tesla Model Y key fob was stolen, treat it as an active security risk—not just an inconvenience. The priority is to prevent the fob from unlocking/starting the car and to restore your access safely.

Understanding Your Situation

A stolen Tesla key fob may still be able to unlock and drive the vehicle if it remains authorized. Unlike traditional keys, your Tesla access is managed through your Tesla account and the vehicle’s “Locks/Keys” settings, so removing the stolen fob and tightening account security are critical.

🚀 Immediate Steps to Take

  1. Secure your Tesla account immediately: change your Tesla account password and enable two-factor authentication (2FA) if it isn’t already on.
  2. Remove the stolen key fob from the car’s authorized keys (Controls > Locks/Keys). If you can’t access the car, use the Tesla app (if available) and contact Tesla Support/Roadside for guidance.
  3. If you believe the vehicle is at risk right now (stolen fob + car location known), move the car to a secure location if possible and file a police report (needed for insurance and documentation).

Your Options

Remove the stolen fob from authorized keys (fastest security fix)

Cost: $0 Time: Same day

Use the car’s touchscreen to delete the stolen key fob from the authorized key list. This prevents that fob from unlocking/starting the vehicle going forward.

âś“ Pros:
  • Immediately reduces theft risk
  • No parts needed
  • Doesn’t require a service visit if you can access the car
âś— Cons:
  • Requires access to the vehicle (or existing app access) to complete quickly
  • If the thief drives off before you remove it, you may be dealing with a vehicle theft situation

Strengthen Tesla account security (password + 2FA)

Cost: $0 Time: Same day

Change your Tesla account password and turn on 2FA to reduce the chance of someone gaining app access (which can also control locks and driving permissions).

âś“ Pros:
  • Protects your vehicle and personal data tied to the Tesla account
  • Prevents unauthorized app control if credentials were compromised
âś— Cons:
  • Doesn’t by itself disable the stolen fob
  • You must maintain access to your email/phone for account recovery

Replace the key fob and pair it to your Model Y

Cost: $175-$250 Time: 1-7 days

Purchase a replacement Tesla key fob and pair it to the vehicle, then confirm the stolen fob is removed. Pairing typically requires an existing authorized key/card and access to the vehicle.

âś“ Pros:
  • Restores a dedicated fob for convenience
  • Allows you to keep a backup access method beyond phone key
âś— Cons:
  • Cost and potential wait time for parts/appointment
  • Pairing may require an existing working key/card and in-person access

Use Tesla Roadside/Service for lockout, security help, and key management

Cost: $0-$300 Time: Same day / 1-3 days

If you can’t access the car or can’t remove the stolen fob, Tesla can help you regain access and guide you through key removal/re-pairing via Service/Roadside support.

âś“ Pros:
  • Best option when you’re locked out or unsure what access remains active
  • Documentation and support for next steps
âś— Cons:
  • Availability varies by location and time
  • Potential service fees depending on situation/warranty/coverage

Insurance claim (if theft, break-in, or vehicle theft occurred)

Cost: Varies (deductible applies) Time: 1-14 days

If the fob was stolen during a break-in, robbery, or the vehicle is stolen/damaged, contact your insurer. A police report and proof of ownership are typically required.

âś“ Pros:
  • May cover replacement costs and related damage
  • Creates an official record for recovery and claims
âś— Cons:
  • May increase premiums depending on policy/history
  • Claim processing can take time

⚠️ What to Avoid

✕ Don’t delay removing the stolen fob from authorized keys—time matters if the thief knows where the car is.

✕ Don’t share Tesla account login codes or reset links with anyone claiming to be “support” (avoid phishing). Use only official Tesla channels.

✕ Don’t rely on changing your Tesla account password alone; it won’t automatically disable a stolen fob that’s already authorized.

⚠️ Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Not deactivating stolen key
  • Delaying reprogramming
  • Not filing police report
  • Ignoring security risk

Frequently Asked Questions

Can someone drive my 2024 Model Y with a stolen key fob?

If the stolen fob is still authorized on your vehicle and the thief can get close enough to the car, it may unlock and allow driving. Remove the fob from the authorized keys list as soon as possible and secure your Tesla account (password + 2FA).

Will changing my Tesla account password disable the stolen key fob?

Not necessarily. Changing your Tesla account password helps protect app access, but an already-authorized key fob can remain valid until it’s removed from the vehicle’s authorized keys.

Can I remove the stolen fob from the Tesla app?

In many cases, key management is done from the vehicle’s touchscreen under Locks/Keys. If you can’t access the car, contact Tesla Support/Service for the fastest safe path to removing the fob and restoring access.

Do I need a police report for a stolen Tesla key fob?

It’s strongly recommended, especially if there’s any risk of vehicle theft, identity theft, or if you plan to file an insurance claim. A report also helps document the timeline and circumstances.

What if my phone key is also compromised?

Immediately change your Tesla account password, enable 2FA, review your account email/phone security, and remove unknown devices/keys from the vehicle. If you suspect your phone is compromised, secure the phone (PIN/biometrics), contact your carrier, and consider a device security scan or reset.

⏱️ Urgency Note: High urgency: a stolen, still-authorized key fob can provide physical access to your Model Y. Remove the fob from authorized keys and secure your Tesla account as soon as possible—ideally immediately.

Related Information

Need Detailed Information?

Get vehicle-specific key fob compatibility, part numbers, and a complete price comparison for your 2024 Tesla Model Y.

View Model Y Key Fob Guide →

Last updated: 2026-01-04